Key Lime Coconut Cream Mini Pies

This shop has been compensated by Collective Bias, Inc. and its advertiser. All opinions are mine alone. #EffortlessPies #CollectiveBias

Key Lime Coconut Cream Mini Pies are the perfect summer dessert! Cool, fresh, healthy, and kid-friendly! Quick & so easy to make! #effortlesspies #ad

According to the calendar it might not officially be summer yet, but here in the south it definitely feels like it is! I’ve had the air conditioner running for over a month already, and the temperatures and my electricity bill are constantly climbing. It’s getting more difficult to concentrate on work because summer makes me dream of going to the beach and lounging by the ocean. Since there’s no beach nearby, I’m bringing the beach home to us with this delicious and ridiculously easy dessert: key lime coconut cream mini pies!

Key Lime Coconut Cream Mini Pies are the perfect summer dessert! Cool, fresh, healthy, and kid-friendly! Quick & so easy to make! #effortlesspies #ad

Yes, I have a thing for lime and coconut together (remember the coconut lime chicken I made?). This dessert is so easy to make that it’s actually effortless. It’s a perfect recipe for your little ones to help make, and it’s healthy. 

During our last family outing at Walmart I saw these Keebler® Ready Crust® Mini Pie Crusts and fell in love with them. And they are mini – about 3-inches wide. Perfect for the kids! So I grabbed some Oikos® Key Lime Greek Yogurt, some coconut greek yogurt, whipped cream cheese, and of course the Reddi-wip® (those were all in the dairy section). You can’t have pie without Reddi-wip®! I wanted a little extra coconut flavor, so I went back down the baking aisle and grabbed the sweetened coconut flakes. And as we went back to the front of the store, I swung through the produce section and grabbed a bag of key limes. 

Key Lime Coconut Cream Mini Pies are the perfect summer dessert! Cool, fresh, healthy, and kid-friendly! Quick & so easy to make! #effortlesspies #ad

Now that you have your shopping done, here comes the hard part – making the pies. Just kidding! These are really effortless! Shopping with kids is way more difficult than making these mini pies! Here’s the recipe:

  • 1 container Oikos® Key Lime Greek Yogurt
  • 1 container coconut greek yogurt
  • 4 ounces whipped cream cheese
  • 2 key limes, juice and zest
  • 1/4 cup sweetened coconut flakes 
  • Keebler® Ready Crust® Mini Graham Cracker Pie Crusts
  • Reddi-wip® for topping

Zest and juice the two key limes. Then in a bowl, mix together the two containers of yogurt, 4 ounces of whipped cream cheese (half of an 8-ounce container – I didn’t even bother measuring it), the coconut flakes, and the key lime zest and juice. Spread out your Keebler® Ready Crust® Mini Graham Cracker Pie Crusts and spoon the mixture into them. I let ours rest in the fridge for about half an hour to let the flavors mingle, but you can serve them immediately if you want to. When you’re ready to eat them, make sure to top them with the Reddi-wip®, and a little extra lime zest for decoration.

Key Lime Coconut Cream Mini Pies are the perfect summer dessert! Cool, fresh, healthy, and kid-friendly! Quick & so easy to make! #effortlesspies #ad

That’s it, that’s all it takes. I don’t think there’s ever been an easier dessert to make. It tastes like summer, and the kids will never know they’re actually eating a healthy dessert. There’s a left-over pie in the fridge (no idea how that happened), and I’m pretty sure my son will be getting that for breakfast this morning. It’s yogurt, so why not?

Key Lime Coconut Cream Mini Pies are the perfect summer dessert! Cool, fresh, healthy, and kid-friendly! Quick & so easy to make! #effortlesspies #ad

These pies also do well in the freezer! If you want to make them ahead for a special occasion or entertaining, mix together your ingredients and fill the Keebler® Ready Crust® Mini Graham Cracker Pie Crusts. Store them in an airtight container in the freezer. Let them thaw in the fridge for a few hours, then top them with the Reddi-wip® when you’re ready to serve.

Key Lime Coconut Cream Mini Pies are the perfect summer dessert! Cool, fresh, healthy, and kid-friendly! Quick & so easy to make! #effortlesspies #ad

If you like this recipe, check out these other effortless mini pies. And make sure you pin this so you can make it, too!

Would you rather have these delicious mini pies for breakfast or dessert? How do you bring the beach home when you can’t get to it? I’d love to hear your thoughts – tell me below in the comments!

Like this post? Join the VIP List!

You'll get access to the VIP Perks page with loads of free goodies including The Step-by-Step Guide to Rocking Your Goals and more! You'll also get exclusive content, new posts, and other great stuff straight to your inbox!

About Samantha

I am a SAHM to three kids and a menagerie of pets. I love coffee, books, crafts, wine, cooking, and more coffee. Seriously, I couldn't function without coffee. Read more about me!


  1. Can’t wait to try this! It sounds amazing!

  2. I love Keylime pie and these little pies are so cute!
    Healing Mama recently posted…The Honest Truth About Making Money As A New Mommy BloggerMy Profile

  3. Nice when they are in individual servings, makes it much easier and fun.

  4. I absolutely adore key lime pies and the fact that these are mini pies is excellent because I could take them on the go!

  5. Such a cute little treat! Key lime is a favorite flavor of mine, and lucky for me I live in Florida where it’s pretty popular. Thanks for sharing!
    Rica @Yoga Mat Monkey recently posted…Dear Penis Poster: Get a ClueMy Profile

  6. Elaine Matthews

    Looks like a great dessert, I like that they are individual little mini pies!! Yum!!

  7. I’ve been searching high and low for something like this to make Memorial Day weekend! Definitely trying this!

    Greta |

  8. I love key lime yogurt, but would never have thought of this! What a great idea!

  9. Key Lime Pie is my husband’s favorite dessert and these are so cute!

  10. Oh, these look good! It would definitely be a dessert for me:)
    Becky @Disney in your day recently posted…Thoughts on the Little MermaidMy Profile

  11. These look AMAZING! Absolutely delicious! I’m always in for lime and coconut!
    Angie recently posted…Be Your Own Boss: Turning Your Passions Into a Successful CareerMy Profile

  12. These look so good! Key lime pies are one of my favorites!

  13. I love everything and anything key lime! And I love that these are so tiny and cute! I am totally making these!

  14. When it comes to planning parties, I’m all about the desserts. And these cute Key Lime Coconut Pies look absolutely delicious! Thank you so much for sharing this sweet recipe and photos. The next time I’m out grocery shopping I’ll look for those ingredients!

  15. How cute are these! I love anything mini!

    Jenna from

  16. Yum! These look absolutely delish!

  17. Wow..This looks so inviting !

  18. Wow I love how easy and delicious these look. Especially love the added touch of lime zest on top.
    Tori recently posted…Hey Parents: You Know it All, Already. You Really Do!My Profile

  19. These look like the perfect summer treat!

  20. These look so cute and delicious!! I’ll definitely be trying these!!

  21. These look really good! My hubby loves key lime pie, maybe I’ll have to whip these up for him at some point 😉 Pinning to share!

  22. Key Lime pie is a summer favorite and I love that you made “mini” versions! So cute!

    • Thanks! After I made them I just stared at them for a minute thinking, “These are so adorable!” 🙂

  23. So yummy 🙂

  24. I absolutely love key lime pies and make them every spring/summer. I never thought to add coconut for some reason, I will definitely have to try it out on my next batch!

    • Kim, in my mind coconut and lime are permanently tied together! Every time I use one of those, I want to add the other flavor. 🙂

  25. Yummy! these look absolutely delicious.

  26. I just recently tried key lime pie for the first time and loved it. Can’t wait to try this version of it.

  27. YUM! This looks amazing! I love key lime flavored anything! Bookmarking to make ASAP!

    xo Ashley

  28. I’m so in love with these! My husband doesn’t like coconut (crazy, right?) so I could make these for myself in mini form and not feel bad 😉

    • You could always make it without the coconut flakes, and just use a second container of key lime yogurt, OR you could have a tasty dessert just for you! 🙂

  29. These look super yummy! seriously, I think the zesting the lime part takes more time than the rest of the maknig of this mini pie. Get in my belly!
    Julie S. @ Fab Working Mom Life recently posted…Tips to Maintain the Work-Mom Life BalanceMy Profile

    • Julie, you’re absolutely right. The zesting took the longest, so that’s why I did it first. Well, aside from going through the grocery store with three kids. 😉

  30. Looks so stylish 🙂 Lime taste add the desired acidity
    Klauss recently posted…Fruit saladsMy Profile

  31. coconut flavor is my favorite one. These sounds interesting!

  32. This sounds like an easy dessert that my whole family would love!
    Heather Davis recently posted…4 Fabulous Uses For Free SamplesMy Profile

  33. These look so delicious! I love that you combined coconut and key lime pies, and that you used Greek yogurt! Thanks for sharing 🙂

  34. I LOVE mini pies! And these look sooooo good!

  35. These pies look scrumptious! Not much of a better combination than key lime and coconut! I love using those tiny pie shells. Something about tiny pies…so cute! — Amy @

  36. Can I have them for breakfast AND dessert? Please? (client)

  37. Ohh my this looks so tasty! I am going to have to make these for my niece. She will love this treat.

  38. Yummy!! Can’t wait to make them!!

  39. Super yummy and cute .
    candy recently posted…Four Cheese Pimiento DipMy Profile

  40. I love this yogurt! What a great way to use it!

  41. My mom will love this. Gonna make them for her as a surprise 😉

  42. These look incredibly amazing! I’ve been craving lime for the last few days! Thanks for sharing!

  43. Yum! Key Lime is my favorite! Pinned 🙂

  44. I love key lime pies! And paired with coconut, that’s just summer in a bite. I didn’t know Keebler made those mini pie crusts. I will definitely look for those next grocery run 🙂 (And to answer your question – I will eat this for breakfast AND dessert AND every meal time in between lol!)

    • The mini pie crusts are adorable, and they taste really good, too! Enjoy them for all the meals, Jolina! 🙂

  45. This looks very good and easy to make.

  46. This looks delicious. I especially love your photos of the items at the grocery store!

  47. I have to pin this. Love anything coconut, and they look so easy to make too. 🙂

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

CommentLuv badge